Plan Your Stay
Let's start planning your perfect Keys getaway. We're here to answer any questions and help make your stay unforgettable.
Send Us a Message
Reserve your waterfront escape in the Florida Keys
Meet Your Hosts
Living the Keys dream since 2015
Sue & Graham
Originally from the UK, Sue and Graham fell in love with the Florida Keys' turquoise waters and laid-back lifestyle. They built A Taste of Sugar as their retirement paradise and love sharing it with guests from around the world.
"This isn't just a rental - it's our slice of paradise, and we're thrilled to share it with you!"
Ready to Book?
Our calendar fills up quickly, especially during peak season and tarpon time.
Quick Response
We typically respond within 2-4 hours
Best Time to Call
9 AM - 7 PM EST
7 days a week
Location
Sugarloaf Key, FL
20 mins to Key West
Booking Tips
Peak Season
December - April books fastest. Reserve 3-6 months ahead!
Fishing Season
May - July for tarpon. Year-round for other species.
Hurricane Season
June - November. We offer flexible rebooking if needed.
Best Value
September - November offers great weather and rates.